Frankie's Taste of Italy

Nestled in the heart of Old Forge, NY, Frankie's Taste of Italy offers a warm and inviting escape into authentic Italian cuisine that will satisfy both your palate and your soul. This charming Italian restaurant at 2824 NY-28 is a must-visit for anyone craving classic flavors crafted with care and passion.

The moment you step inside Frankie’s, you are embraced by a cozy, family-style atmosphere that feels like dining at a beloved relative’s home. The staff exudes genuine hospitality, creating an environment where every guest feels valued and welcome—whether you’re a large group or a couple seeking a quiet night out.

The menu is a vibrant celebration of Italy’s rich culinary tradition, boasting standout dishes that ignite the senses. Crisp, refreshing salads drizzled with their signature house balsamic dressing set the perfect stage. For starters, the Deep Fried Calamari with Marinara Sauce offers a tantalizing crunch paired with a tangy tomato dip that instantly whets your appetite.

If seafood tempts you, the Cioppino showcases a briny medley of the sea, perfectly simmered in a rich, savory broth, while the Grilled Salmon is delicately seasoned and grilled to flaky perfection. Pasta lovers will find heaven in the Rigatoni Con Fungi, where tender rigatoni is enveloped in a luscious mushroom sauce with an earthy depth of flavor. The Chicken Cacciatore and Chicken French dishes offer comforting, hearty options bursting with traditional Italian herbs and vibrant sauces.

Completing the meal with dessert is an absolute must here. Dive into the creamy decadence of their Chocolate Mousse, or cool off with the house-made Pistachio and Mixed Fruit Gelato, which delightfully balances sweetness with smooth, creamy textures. And for those who appreciate a perfect sip alongside their meal, Frankie's thoughtfully crafted drinks menu features selections like the elegant Italy Moscato and refreshing, fruit-forward Sangria.

What truly sets Frankie's apart is the heartfelt care woven into every aspect of the experience—from the impeccable food quality to the attentive service. Reviewers unanimously praise the restaurant’s welcoming vibe and exceptional flavors. Brittany Grossman highlights the family feel and phenomenal food, while Chris Schneible raves about the seafood and homemade salad dressing, deeming it the best dinner spot in Old Forge. Regular visitor Sue Keating admits Frankie’s has become an essential destination for every trip to the area thanks to its delightful atmosphere and perfectly cooked pasta.

Even with busy nights and full bookings, the staff at Frankie's handle the crowd with professionalism and warmth, making waiting worth every minute. Jeff R’s suggestion for a small wine offering during longer waits speaks to the attentive nature of the team eager to enhance your dining experience.

Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion, seeking comforting Italian classics, or simply wanting to indulge in top-tier cuisine in a welcoming setting, Frankie's Taste of Italy invites you to savor every bite and cherish every moment. Make sure to book ahead—this gem is a beloved staple in Old Forge that fills up quickly for good reason!